Why Top Brokers Are Losing Active Investors Despite Rising Markets
Why Investor Activity Is Dropping Even When the Market Is Up
Why Top Brokers Are Losing Active Investors Despite Rising Markets
Introduction
At a time when the Indian stock market is showing signs of strength—with gains of over 9% in just two months—you’d expect retail investor activity to be surging. Instead, the opposite is happening. India’s top stockbrokers, including Groww, Zerodha, Angel One, and Upstox, are facing a steady decline in active investors for the third month in a row.
This puzzling trend reveals deeper changes brewing beneath the surface of India’s retail investing landscape.
What’s Behind the Decline?
Market Recovery Isn’t Enough
The NSE data shows that even as benchmark indices gained over 3% in April (on top of a 6% rally in March), investor activity continued to shrink. The drop in users seems to lag the market movement, which isn’t unusual. Sentiment among retail traders tends to recover slowly, especially after the 20% correction seen between September 2024 and February 2025.
But this time, the lag seems to be deeper and more persistent.
The Numbers Tell the Story
- Groww and Angel One each saw about 75,000 fewer active investors in April 2025.
- Zerodha lost 55,000+ users, continuing a five-month downward streak.
- Since its peak, Groww has lost nearly 3 lakh active users, falling from 1.32 crore.
- Zerodha’s active base has shrunk from 81 lakh to 78 lakh since November 2024.
With over 16 crore demat accounts but only around 5 crore unique investors, this drop reflects a cautious and possibly fatigued retail base.
Why Are Investors Pulling Back?
Several factors are contributing to this surprising slowdown in retail trading:
1. Tighter Futures & Options Regulations
Since late 2024, regulators have introduced stricter rules around F&O trading—a favourite among active traders. These changes are meant to protect inexperienced investors from excessive risk, but they’ve also led to a steep decline in trading volumes.
2. Increased Tax Burden and Lower Incentives
Higher taxes on trades and reduced exchange rebates are hitting both traders and brokers. With profits being squeezed, many investors—especially the smaller ones—are simply opting out.
3. Geopolitical & Economic Uncertainty
Concerns around the India-Pakistan conflict, Donald Trump’s tariff moves, and underwhelming Q4 earnings have created a jittery investment environment. Many retail traders are choosing to wait and watch.
Not All Brokers Are Losing
Interestingly, while discount brokers are seeing a decline, traditional bank-backed brokers like HDFC Securities, ICICI Securities, SBI Cap, and Yes Securities have continued to add active investors over the past six months.
At the same time, emerging platforms like INDMoney, Dhan, and PhonePe’s Share. Market is gaining traction—suggesting that while overall activity may be slowing, investors are re-evaluating where and how they invest.
Brokers Feeling the Heat
The financial impact of this trend is already showing up in earnings:
- Angel One, the only listed top broker, reported a 49% fall in net profit for Q4 FY25.
- Revenue dropped by 22% to ₹1,056 crore from ₹1,357 crore a year earlier.
- The company cited a tougher regulatory environment and geopolitical headwinds as key reasons for the decline.
Privately held players like Zerodha and Groww haven’t released earnings yet, but analysts expect a 30–50% hit to revenues across the sector in the second half of FY25.
What This Means for the Market
The ongoing decline in active users among top brokers isn’t just a short-term blip—it’s a sign of a changing market. Investors are becoming more selective. Trading patterns are shifting. The era of explosive retail growth, driven by low fees and mobile-first apps, may be entering a new, more mature phase.
Conclusion
The decline in active investors at India’s top brokers, despite a rising market, reflects deeper undercurrents—regulatory changes, economic uncertainty, and shifting investor behaviour. It’s a wake-up call for broking platforms to rethink their strategies and focus not just on acquisition, but on education, experience, and long-term engagement.
The coming quarters will test how well these platforms can adapt. For now, the message from retail investors is clear: enthusiasm alone isn’t enough—they want clarity, confidence, and value.
Related Post
India’s Defence Stocks on Fire: Why Shipbuilders Are the Market’s New Powerhouses
Read more
"The Hidden Price of Instant Money: Should You Really Take That Unsecured Loan?"
Read more
Cabinet Secretary Steps in to Prevent Action Against MTNL: What’s at Stake?
Read more
IRDAI Proposes Major Shift in Bancassurance: From Commission to Transaction Fee
Read more
The Legends of Indian Cricket: Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli – A Legacy to Remember
Read more
Swiggy Q4 FY25: Rising Losses, But Revenue Growth Shows Hope for the Future
Read more
Yes Bank's Big Move: What SMBC's Investment Means for India's Banking Sector
Read more
Market Bounce Back: How Border Peace, Strong Earnings, and FII Investments Are Lifting Stock Prices?
Read more
Regulatory Shift in Financial Services: Focus on Fintech and Consumer Protection
Read more
IMF Approves $1B Loan to Pakistan: Why India Abstained & What the Vote Means Geopolitically?
Read more
Gold Prices Rise Slightly Across Indian Cities Today (10 May 2025) – Is This a Trend Shift?
Read more
Why Sharekhan Is Bullish on Nippon Life India AMC With a Target of Rs 800
Read more
Hindustan Unilever Earnings Breakdown: Surprises & Signals for the Market
Read more
IndusInd Bank Share Price Update: What Today’s Movement Means for Investors
Read more
BAF Don’t Blink: Discover the Hidden Strength of Balanced Advantage Funds for Steady Growth
Read more
Infosys Layoffs Employees: What the Shocking Job Cuts Mean for India's IT Sector
Read more
GST on UPI Transactions: Is Your Free Digital Payment System About to Change?
Read more
Waaree Renewables Share Price Soars: What’s Fueling the Green Energy Surge?
Read more
Why BluSmart’s Electric Taxi Fleet Is Just the Beginning—Thanks to Gensol’s Vision
Read more
SIP Surge: How Retail Investors Are Fueling a ₹2.9 Lakh Crore Spike in FY25
Read more
Trump’s Auto Comeback Plan: How Car Companies Moving from Mexico & Canada Could Change Everything
Read more
India’s Next Retail Giant? Amazon-Backed More Retail Plans IPO with Game-Changing Model
Read more
Nifty Auto Index Signals Reversal: Decoding the Bullish Black Swan Pattern
Read more
Nifty IT Surges on Trump Tariff Pause; Coforge, Wipro, Infosys Lead Rally
Read more
Godrej Consumer Eyes Volume Revival and Margin Stability: A Bullish Outlook?
Read more
Markets Tumble: S&P 500 and Dow Close Lower Amid Tariff and Inflation Fears
Read more
Tata Motors Share Price Analysis: Trends, Predictions, and Investment Insights for 2025
Read more
Bandhan Bank Q3 Results: Net Profit Declines 42% to ₹427 Crore, NII Rises 12% to ₹2,830 Crore
Read more
AU Small Finance Bank Q3 FY25 Results: Net Profit Surpasses Estimates Despite Asset Quality Pressures
Read more
Polycab Q3 Results: Stock Rebounds After Strong Guidance and Better-Than-Expected EBITDA
Read more
IndiaMART Intermesh Q3 Results: Net Profit Jumps 48% to ₹121 Crore, Revenue Grows 16%
Read more
Zomato Q3 Results: Blinkit Remains Loss-Making as Expansion Accelerates
Read more
Paytm Q3 Results: Narrowed Losses and Focus on Five Key Profitability Drivers
Read more
Axis Bank Reports 4% Rise in Q3 Net Profit Amid Slowest Advances and Deposits Growth in 15 Quarters
Read more
Transrail Lighting Q2 Results: Net Profit Rises 22% to ₹58 Crore, Revenue Up 12%
Read more
LTTS Q3 Results: Net Profit at ₹322 Crore; Aims for 10% Revenue Growth in FY25
Read more
IRFC Emerges as the Lowest Bidder to Finance ₹3,167 Crore for Jharkhand Coal Mine Development
Read more
CESC Q3 Results: Net Profit Declines to ₹265 Crore, Revenue Rises by 10%
Read more
Vodafone Idea Clears Outstanding Dues to Indus Towers with Parent's Capital Infusion
Read more
Cigniti Shares Fall 7% After Coforge Announces Amalgamation and Share Swap Ratio
Read more
Mamata Machinery Share Price Updates: Blockbuster Listing at ₹630 on NSE, 159.26% Premium to IPO Price
Read more
Quess Corp Shares Stay Volatile Post Karnataka HC's Landmark Verdict on ₹180 Crore Tax Demand
Read more
ACME Solar Secures ₹1,988 Crore Financing and Wins SECI 300 MW Solar Bid
Read more
Adani Group Acquires Air Works to Strengthen Defence and Aviation Business
Read more
Adani Green Energy Commissions 250 MW Solar Power Project in Rajasthan
Read more
Vodafone Idea shares are now 25% below their FPO price ahead of December 9 board meet
Read more
Suzlon Energy Secures 302.4 MW Wind Project from Jindal Renewables in Karnataka
Read more
Varun Beverages Shares Dip 5% on GST Hike Proposal to 35% for Aerated Beverages
Read more
Yes Bank Returns to F&O Segment After Four Years: A Look at Its Journey
Read more
Stock market crash: Why is Indian stock market falling? Explained with five crucial reasons
Read more
NTPC Green Energy Share Price Updates: Stock Extends Gain After Lukewarm Debut
Read more
Stock Market Today: Nifty 50 Surges Over 400 Points, Sensex Reclaims 80K
Read more
Adani Group Stocks: Recovery Amid Sharp Volatility After $27 Billion Rout
Read more
Adani Bribery Case: A Timeline of Events Between Adani, Azure, and SECI
Read more
Godavari Biorefineries Makes Disappointing Market Debut; Lists at a 13% Discount
Read more
Canara Bank Q2 Results: Net Profit Climbs 11%, Asset Quality Shows Improvement
Read more
Suzlon Energy Q2 Results: Revenue Surges Past ₹2,000 Crore, Net Profit Nearly Doubles
Read more
Yes Bank Q2FY25 Results: Net Profit Jumps 10% QoQ, Total Income Rises 2.45%
Read more
Bandhan Bank Q2 FY25 Results: Net Profit Jumps 30% to ₹937 Crore, Beating Estimates
Read more
Bank of Baroda Q2 FY25 Results: Key Highlights and Performance Overview
Read more
Hyundai Motor's Q3 Operating Profit Drops 7%, Misses Analysts' Estimates
Read more
Aster DM Healthcare Shares Surge 10% Post Strong Q2 Results, Tops Nifty 500 Gainers
Read more
Godrej Properties Q2 FY25 Results: Achieves 51% of Annual Booking Guidance in First Half
Read more
PNC Infratech Loses ₹3,200 Crore in Market Cap After a 27% Fall in Two Sessions
Read more
Paytm Stock Drops 4% as Rs 930 Crore Q2 Profit Fails to Impress Investors
Read more
Hyundai Motor India Listing: Shares of India's largest IPO debut at a discount to issue price
Read more
Gravita India Q2 Results: Net Profit Rises 26% to ₹72 Crore; Revenue Grows 11% to ₹927 Crore
Read more
HDFC Bank Q2 FY25 Results: Net Profit Rises 5% to Rs 16,821 Crore, Beating Estimates
Read more
Tech Mahindra Q2 Earnings: Profit Surges 153% YoY, Interim Dividend Declared
Read more
ICICI Lombard Q2 Results: Net Profit Jumps 20% to ₹694 Crore, Declares Interim Dividend
Read more
Tata Consumer Products Q2 Results: Net Profit Stays Flat at ₹359 crore, Beats Estimates
Read more
Oberoi Realty Q2 Results: Net Profit Jumps 28% to ₹589 Crore, Declares Second Interim Dividend
Read more
Manappuram Finance Shares Plunge 15% to 11-Month Low After RBI Action and Multiple Downgrades
Read more
Axis Bank Q2 FY25 Results: Net Profit Up 18%, Operating Profit Rises 24%
Read more
Infosys Q2 FY25 Results - Revenue Growth Guidance Raised, Strong Performance Continues
Read more
Bajaj Auto Share Price Drops Over 10% After Q2 Results: Should You Buy the Stock?
Read more
L&T Technology Services Announces Interim Dividend of ₹17 Per Share, Fixes Record Date
Read more
TVS Holdings Board to Consider Fundraising Via Non-Convertible Debentures on October 23
Read more
SEBI Increases Index F&O Position Limits for Trading Members to ₹7,500 Crore
Read more
Hyundai Motor India IPO: Key Risks Investors Should Be Aware of Before Subscribing to the ₹27,870 Crore Issue
Read more
IREDA Q2 Results: Net profit jumps 36.2% on year to ₹387.75 crore, revenue up 41.3%
Read more
VA Tech Wabag Rises 4% After Bagging Major Repeat Orders from Reliance Industries
Read more
Suzlon Energy Shares Decline to a Two-Month Low: Eight Consecutive Days in Red
Read more
Tech Mahindra Shares Receive a Boost with CLSA Upgrade Ahead of Earnings Report
Read more
Bharti Airtel Clears ₹8,465 Crore Spectrum Liabilities to Strengthen Balance Sheet
Read more
KRN Heat Exchanger IPO Day 1: Strong Demand, GMP, Subscription Status, and Key Insights
Read more
Punjab National Bank Announces QIP at ₹109.16 per Share: Key Details Revealed
Read more
Vodafone Idea Shares Surge After $3.6 Billion Capex Deal with Vendors
Read more
HDFC Bank Stock Gains as Board Approves HDB Financial Services IPO Proposal
Read more
SpiceJet Board Approves ₹3,000 Crore QIP; Issues 48.7 Crore Shares at ₹61.60 Each
Read more
ION Exchange Surges 8% After Securing ₹161 Crore Order from Adani Power
Read more
Fed Meeting Outcome: Nifty IT Index Falls Nearly 3% Amid Market Uncertainty
Read more
Bajaj Housing Finance Extends Gains After 135% Listing Day Surge: Should Investors Book Profits?
Read more
Suzlon Energy Hits 5% Upper Circuit on Morgan Stanley Earnings Boost Prediction
Read more
Suzlon Energy Secures Largest Renewable Energy Order from NTPC Green Energy
Read more
Varun Beverages Announces Record Date for Stock Split; Shares Edge Higher
Read more
SEBI Tightens Criteria for Stocks in F&O Segment: A New Era of Market Quality Control
Read more
Nifty Pharma Reaches Record High as Three Stocks Gain Over 100% in a Year
Read more
Major Block Deal: IndiGo Shares Worth Over $1 Billion Change Hands, Rakesh Gangwal Likely Seller
Read more
Zee Entertainment Shares Surge After Announcing Settlement Agreement with Sony India
Read more
IRFC to replace LIC in the Nifty PSE index but railway PSU sees selling pressure
Read more
AU Small Finance Bank Sees Significant Block Deal: 1.7% Equity Changes Hands Worth ₹804 Crore
Read more
Zomato Sees ₹5,438.50 Crore Block Deal as Antfin Singapore Likely Divests Stake
Read more
Piramal Enterprises Stock Plunges Over 8% as Q1 Net Profit Falls 64% YoY: What Should Investors Do?
Read more
Hindenburg Research Hints at New Target in India: Cryptic Message Sparks Speculation
Read more
Bharti Hexacom Q1 Results: Net Profit Soars to ₹511 Crore, Revenue Up 14%
Read more
HAL Shares Extend Losses to 20% from Record High, but Still Trade Above Historical Valuations
Read more
Hindustan Zinc Q1 Results: Net Profit Surges Nearly 20%, Margin Expands 250 Basis Points
Read more
Titagarh Rail Systems Sees 8% Decline in Stock Following Subdued Q1 Earnings
Read more
Federal Bank Q1 Results: Net Profit Climbs 18% to ₹1,009.5 Crore, NII Jumps 20%
Read more
Bajaj Finance Q1 Results: Net Profit of ₹3,912 Crore Meets Estimates, Asset Quality Stable
Read more
Wipro Shares Plummet After Disappointing Q1 Results, Marking Biggest Drop in 4 Years
Read more
Garden Reach Shipbuilders Secures ₹840 Crore Order from National Centre for Polar and Ocean Research
Read more
Suzlon Energy Sees ₹50 Crore Block Deals; Major Announcement Expected on July 22
Read more
DMart Share Price Rises Over 4% After Avenue Supermarts Reports Strong Q1 Results
Read more
IREDA Q1 Results: Net Profit Soars by 30% Amid Strong Asset Quality and Loan Growth
Read more
Zee Entertainment Announces Board Meeting to Consider Fund Raising; Stock Surges 6%
Read more
GM Breweries Q1 Results: Shares Rise After 25% Profit Growth and Margin Expansion
Read more
₹900 Crore Fund Infusion Boosts Inox Wind and Inox Wind Energy Stocks by Up to 15%
Read more
Polycab Shares Fall After Block Deals Worth ₹2,716 Crore; Promoters Likely Sellers
Read more
Quant Mutual Fund Faces SEBI Probe for Alleged Front-Running: Should Investors Worry?
Read more
KEI Industries Stock Jumps Over 3% as Labour Strike Ends; Production Loss Limited to ₹10 Crore
Read more
Hyundai Motor India Files for Historic IPO with SEBI, Plans to Sell 14.2 Crore Shares
Read more
Puravankara to Raise ₹1,000 Crore Through Qualified Institutional Placement (QIP)
Read more
Adani's Ambuja Cements Expands with ₹10,422 Crore Penna Cement Acquisition
Read more
Vodafone Idea to Reduce Debt by Issuing ₹2,458 Crore in Preferential Shares to Nokia and Ericsson
Read more
IRB Infra Block Deal: 6.8% Equity Worth ₹2,656 Crore Changes Hands in Large Trade
Read more
Mphasis Block Deal: 15.6% Equity Changes Hands in Large Trade; Blackstone Likely Seller
Read more
Edelweiss Financial Shares Drops 17% Following RBI Action Against Two Entities
Read more
KPI Green Energy Soars: Stock Split Announced After Bonus Issue and Record Performance
Read more
📢 IREDA Clarifies FPO Rumors: No Decision Yet, Strong Financial Growth Reported Here’s What the Management Said
Read more
